Once Done, No Reversal For Ambulance Station Closures
December 5th 2012In August when I first heard about East Midlands Ambulance Service's plans to shake up the way ambulance stations are organised I'll admit I was on the fence. Knowing nothing of how ambulances stations operated, I was willing to consider that EMAS could have a workable plan for improving response times and maintaining an acceptable level of service for the public. I thought: these people work in the ambulance service, maybe they know what's best for it? Everything I've learnt since then has underlined how thumb-suckingly naive that position was.
The real expertsAt the town council meeting of 27th November we heard from the real experts, those who work in the ambulance service locally, rather than just the upper management. The staff of Louth Ambulance Station wrote to EMAS outlining their concerns, and their proposals for alternative changes.
You say potato, I say portacabinThe major change suggested in the Being The Best consultation document is replacing existing ambulance stations with five large hub stations, in Lincolnshire, and a lot of "community ambulance points" or "standby points", only one of which will be in Louth. There's no picture of standby points in the document, but they are basically just portacabins and portaloos.
In their letter to EMAS, Louth Ambulance Station staff had this to say:
When I spoke to Jackie Featherstone, who is co-ordinating the campaign to save Louth ambulance station, she explained the security concern more clearly. Paramedics need to administer morphine and similar drugs, and these need to be kept in safes. But it's easy to break into a portacabin. The first part of portacabin refers to the fact that it's portable, but if you need to move one of these you're either left with a drugs safe concreted to the floor, or you don't have a secure location for keeping medicines in the first place.
CostsAmbulance workers wrote of their concerns that a lot of the costs of these changes haven't been taken into account. These are not limited to the increased staff travelling expenses to hub stations.
This echoes the criticisms Councillor Brian Burnett has made at previous town council meetings.
Travel timesWhen it comes to staff welfare, the letter made a lot of points about how this change would impact on travel times.
Driving to Skegness from Louth takes around 40 minutes on a good day, which makes for a lot of wasted petrol and time.
No going back if hubs failThe all-encompassing nature of the proposed changes are another cause for alarm:
I can think of another man who made sweeping changes to a vital community service: Dr Richard Beeching, when he closed down all the railway branch lines. Louth still hasn't recovered from that disaster, which shows how hard it can be to reinstate services and infrastructure once land and buildings get sold.
TargetsThe impetus behind these changes is the fact that EMAS is missing its response targets. With so-called "red category" calls, those that are serious and life threatening, it is meant to respond to 75% of these calls within 8 minutes and 95% within 19 minutes. Actual figures for 2011/12 indicate ambulances arrive at 75.15% of these within 8 minutes, and 92.32% within 19 minutes.
That sounds bad, but not a complete disaster, and it's at least an improvement on the figures for previous years. However what these figures don't show is the enormous variation within those response times, as illustrated by some of the horror stories that have come to light recently.
What I don't see is how anything EMAS is proposing could possibly have a positive effect on response times, especially in Louth. We're not getting a lot of new standby points, because most of the 28 that are earmarked for spots in Lincolnshire will be in the south of the county. And we're not getting any more ambulance staff or vehicles, which is what would really make a difference.
Petition signaturesSo far 2246 people have signed a petition opposing the closure of Louth Ambulance Station. David Hall has been out campaigning for Save Louth Ambulances. He found that a lot of people were disappointed about the level of public consultation by EMAS, but once they understood what was at stake the response to the petition was overwhelmingly favourable.
Send in your news or comments
Similar ArticlesHospital Marchers Are Right To Be Worried
People who marched through Louth in support of the NHS and hospital services are right to be worried.
People Demonstrate In Louth Against NHS Cuts
On 21st January people of all ages came together to demonstrate about the crisis in the NHS and against the continuing austerity that puts it under threat.
Round-Up: School Transport Costs And A Stroke Consultation
FOI information reveals the high cost of school transport, and the public have a limited time to have a say about threatened acute stroke services in Grimsby.
Pictures From The 2013 Run For Life
People raced through Louth in the annual event in aid of Cancer Research UK. Every year the costumes seem to get wackier.
Wind Power, Housing on Chequergate, and Ambulances
Wind power proves popular with some town councillors, but they don't have the final say on turbine plans.